Skip to main content
Legal Procurement

Buyer’s guide

Buying solicitors’ professional indemnity insurance

How solicitors' PII renewal works: choosing a broker, the SRA minimum terms, the renewal timetable, proposal forms, what drives premium and run-off.

Updated 21 November 2026 ยท 6 minute read

In this guide

For most firms regulated by the SRA in England and Wales, professional indemnity insurance is the one purchase they cannot skip. A firm that needs qualifying cover and can't get it will have to stop practising. Start the renewal early so your broker has time to approach participating insurers. It also helps to present the firm clearly and work with a broker who knows the solicitors' market.

If you own the renewal as managing partner, COFA or practice manager, check the detail of what your firm needs against the current SRA rules and with your COLP and COFA. Nothing here is legal advice.

What the rules require

Firms within the scope of the SRA Indemnity Insurance Rules must hold professional indemnity insurance that meets the SRA's minimum terms and conditions. Some licensed bodies have terms of authorisation that work differently, so check where your firm sits. The policy has to come from a participating insurer, which is an insurer that has signed an agreement with the SRA to offer cover on those terms. The SRA publishes the list of participating insurers, and it is worth checking that any insurer you are offered is on it.

The minimum terms set a floor. They fix the minimum level of cover per claim, which differs depending on how the firm is structured, and they limit the exclusions and conditions an insurer can apply against a client's claim. Many firms buy more than the minimum, either because their work carries larger risks or because clients and lenders ask for it. Cover above the minimum is called top-up or excess layer cover and can come from a wider range of insurers.

The minimum terms protect clients. They are about civil liability for the firm's legal work. First-party losses, such as the cost of recovering from a cyber attack or the firm's own lost income, are outside what the minimum terms require. Many firms buy a separate cyber policy for that, and it is worth asking your broker how the two policies fit together.

Plan around your renewal date

Each policy has its own renewal date, and the rules don't set a common one. Ask your broker whether yours falls at a busy point in the market, when underwriters and brokers are handling many firms at once. Whatever the date, a late or incomplete submission goes to the back of the queue.

Work back from the renewal date. A realistic timetable looks something like this:

  1. Several months out, review the last renewal, your claims and any changes in the firm, and talk to your broker about the market.
  2. Gather the information for the proposal form while there is still time to fix gaps, such as an out-of-date risk register or file reviews that have slipped.
  3. Submit a complete proposal in good time so the broker can approach insurers properly.
  4. Leave time to review quotes, ask questions and agree terms before the deadline.

If a firm reaches its renewal date without qualifying cover, the minimum terms give it a 30-day extended indemnity period, then a 60-day cessation period. Both periods put limits on new work, and the firm must close at the end unless it finds qualifying cover. The SRA also expects to be told. Speak to your broker and the SRA early if renewal looks difficult.

Using a broker

Many firms buy through a broker. A specialist broker knows which insurers are writing which kinds of firm, how underwriters will read your proposal, and how to present your risk management so it counts, and can tell you whether a quote is reasonable for your profile.

When you choose or review a broker, ask:

  • How many solicitors' practices like yours do they place each year, and with which participating insurers?
  • Who will handle your renewal day to day, and how much experience do they have?
  • How do they get paid: commission from the insurer, a fee from you, or both? Ask them to disclose it.
  • What help do they give with the proposal form, and will they review it before it goes out?
  • What do they do between renewals, such as help with claims notifications or risk management?

Changing broker close to renewal is possible but makes the process harder. If you are unhappy, raise it soon after a renewal, not weeks before the next.

You can find brokers and insurers that work with law firms in our solicitors' PII category.

Preparing the proposal form

The proposal form is how an underwriter decides whether to offer cover and at what price. A clear, complete and accurate form is one of the few parts of the process the firm controls. Vague answers, missing figures or surprises found later make underwriters cautious.

Expect questions about:

  • fee income, split by work type, and how it has changed
  • the proportion of conveyancing and other higher-risk work
  • the firm's structure, number of principals and staff, and offices
  • claims and circumstances notified, with the current position on each
  • supervision arrangements, file reviews and how trainees and junior staff are overseen
  • how the firm handles client money and protects against payment fraud
  • cyber controls and staff training
  • any regulatory issues, mergers, acquisitions or new work types

Check every figure against your accounts before it goes in. Make sure the claims history matches what your current insurer holds. If something has gone wrong, explain it and say what you changed afterwards. Underwriters expect firms to have problems. They want to see that you deal with them.

Supporting documents help. A short risk management summary, evidence of file reviews, your policies on supervision and cyber security, and any accreditations you hold all give the underwriter something concrete.

The duty of fair presentation under the Insurance Act 2015 applies. That means disclosing what the firm knows or ought to know that would influence a prudent insurer, or at least giving enough for the insurer to ask further questions. Getting it wrong can cause problems if a claim arises. Your broker can advise on what to include.

What drives the premium

Every insurer prices differently, but the same factors come up at most renewals:

  • Work type. Conveyancing, wills and probate, and some other areas carry a history of claims and are priced accordingly.
  • Claims record. Past claims, and especially open ones, weigh heavily.
  • Size and fee income. Cover is broadly priced against the scale of the practice.
  • Risk management. Firms that can show real supervision, file review and fraud controls tend to be viewed more favourably.
  • Cover level and excess. More cover costs more; a higher excess can bring the premium down but leaves the firm carrying more of each claim.
  • Changes in the firm. Rapid growth, a merger, or new work types draw questions.

Payment fraud and cyber incidents deserve a mention of their own. Underwriters ask about them closely, because a single diverted completion payment can lead to a large claim. Being able to show how you verify bank details and train staff helps.

Run-off cover

When a firm closes without a successor practice, the minimum terms provide six years of run-off cover, which protects clients against claims that come in after the firm has stopped. In some circumstances a firm that does have a successor can elect for run-off instead. Run-off is provided by the firm's last insurer, and its cost is usually charged at the point of closure.

Run-off is a reason to plan any retirement, closure or merger well ahead. Whether a new firm counts as a successor practice affects who picks up claims for old work, and the answer depends on the facts. Take advice early, and talk to your broker before any deal is agreed.

The SRA has reviewed its approach to PII and run-off in recent years. Check the current position on its website rather than relying on what applied when you last renewed.

Before you sign

Read the policy schedule and any endorsements, not just the quote. Check the insured entity, the cover level, the excess, the aggregate position on any top-up layer, and the start and end dates. Make sure any conditions in the quote, such as completing a risk survey, are things the firm can do.

Loans to spread the premium are listed with the other insurance and finance suppliers, and our other buyer's guides include one on Cyber Essentials, which underwriters may ask about. If you are reviewing brokers or looking for top-up or cyber cover ahead of the next renewal, start with our professional indemnity category.

Browse PII brokers and insurers

Each listing shows the company facts and where they came from. We're adding suppliers in this category.

Browse PII brokers and insurers